A Few Words on Prediction Markets
A recent conversation with a friend made me made realize how easy it is to be misinterpreted, especially on more complex issues.
Let me clarify my views on the so-called prediction markets.
In the past, I have very strongly dissed some people’s concept of these markets and their ability to “predict” the future. The primary reason for my view is the unfortunate tendency for some people to place way to much faith in the crowd to know the unknowable.
I have yet to see a reasonable explanation as to why IEM missed Dean's collapse in the primaries; a commentor notes that the American Idol contract on Tradesports had Bice 90% favored in the final minutes -- but lost.
That said, I rely on many forms of market action to provide color to my expectations. Trend Following is one obvious area. The Fed futures are another. All of technical analysis requires interpreting price and volume changes. I would be lying if I said I didn’t think the Bond market was saying something.
So when I dis prediction markets -- especially about their lack of liquidity and small trading pool -- its a slight. It reflects my general disdain for the efficient market hypothesis, amongst other flawed theoretical concepts. When it comes to explaining market behavior, I'm more of a Chaos-theory man myself.
The difference between the Bond market and say, the Iowa Electronic Markets, NewsFutures and the Hollywood Stock Exchange or Trade Sports is in the size, scale, and liquidity. I am agnostic about these smaller markets, but I do not discount the possibility that any mechanism can potentially provide some insight into future market behaviors.
On a related note, I am reading (quite skeptically) the Wisdom of Crowds -- something quite related to the concept of prediction markets. Its a book that I find slow going because of the continual fisking it requires. While its a pleasure to read Surowiecki's prose, on most of the market related items I’ve gone through there are readily identified logical flaws and unsupported assumptions. (More on this in the future).
As to the Prediction markets value, I remain an interested skeptic.
If you want to learn more about Prediction Markets, than the meta page you want to see is Chris Masse’s prediction market vortal. There's a ton of data and links there to get you started . . .
TrackBack URL for this entry:
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference A Few Words on Prediction Markets :
» Prediction Markets -Another View (via The Big Pic from Financial Rounds
As I've written previously, I'm a big fan of prediction markets (both as a classroom tool and as a means of extracting information from dispersed groups). However, Barry Ritholz at The Big Bicture has a less favorable view: [Read More]
Tracked on May 27, 2005 9:33:24 AM
The markets you talk of don't necessarily predict the future of an event, they are just an idea of the consensus' view of the event. And as you know, the consensus view is not always correct. Check out the results of the American Idol contract on tradesports http://www.tradesports.com/jsp/intrade/contractSearch/searchPageBuilder.jsp?z=1117168465403&expired=true
Bice was 90% favored in the final minutes but lost.
Posted by: unan | May 27, 2005 12:36:35 AM
The comments to this entry are closed.