Anti-Bubble or Anti-Inflation?
As we have been discussing for some time, Real Estate remains the most robust sector of the economy.
reveals the reason why the Fed
faces a Hobson's choice is between a rock and a hard place: Either keep raising rates, in order to cool off
what is obviously a hot sector, which, while not quite a bubble yet, is at risk for becoming, one. The Fed missed the opportunity to let some air gently out of the tech stock bubble in 1999; surely, they do not want to (once again) miss yet opportunity to avoid a bloodletting.
Ahhh, but here's the rub: doing so risks smothering the most vigorous source of U.S. growth -- the Real Estate complex of builders, contractors, mortgage underwriters, etc.
Let's add another element into the mix, just to complicate things: Inflation. Here's the rub -- I'm not sure the Fed can do much to stop this present flavor of inflation. This is a non-monetary inflation, one with zero wage based pressures. Health care, education costs, oil, copper, concrete, aluminium, dairy products, meat chicken -- how much impact will another half dozen or so 1/4 point increases have on any of these prices? Most of these are rising independent of monetary policy.
It may be that the only way the Fed can slow these price increases is to induce a Recession. Is that what they are thinking -- cause a recession to slow price increases? (I hope not).
While they attempt to walk the razor's edge, we should remain cognizant that inflation is also a natural response to healthy growth. Demand for raw materials rise, Targetting inflation by removing the "accomodation" has some pretty foreseeable effects: reducing finance driven manufacturing, auto sales, and of course, real estate.
The one peculiarly disconcerting issue is why interest long rates have not gone up, assuming that 1) trhis is a healthy expansion, and b)the demand for Capital is as robust as some economists claim.
While we are discussing Real Estate, I would be remiss if I did not point to a pair of posts from Calculated Risk on new home sales in the US:
click for larger graphic
For more on this subject, see:
Update: May 3, 2005 12:03pm
The WSJ's Steve Liesman asks a similar question: "Is the Fed trying to pop the housing bubble?"
"[E]ither Mr. Kohn is clueing us in to a change in thinking by the chairman, or he is parting with the chairman in some significant areas.
Everywhere Mr. Kohn looks, he sees imbalances in the economy. The trade deficit is too large, as is the federal budget deficit. The savings rate is too low, as are long-term interest rates. And the housing market looks clearly to be the focus of speculation. "The climate of low interest rates has in turn bolstered asset markets in some countries, especially residential real estate markets,'' he says. He also notes, more ominously, that "recent reports from professionals in the housing market suggest an increasing volume of transactions by investors …''
At times in the speech, the Fed governor is optimistic about how these imbalances work themselves out, as long as the FOMC sets the right policy.
"Ideally, the transition would be made without disturbing the relatively tranquil macroeconomic environment that we now enjoy,'' he said. This is sort of the party line. Yet in the next sentence, Mr. Kohn says, "But the size and persistence of the current imbalances pose a risk that the transition may prove more disruptive."
The Fed Beyond Inflation
Steve Liesman's Macro Investor
A Governor's Remarks On Economic Wrinkles Could Signal Shift at Fed
April 29, 2005
TrackBack URL for this entry:
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Anti-Bubble or Anti-Inflation?:
» Can McMansions Be Inflationary? from The Personal Finance Weblog
Barry Ritholtz has a piece on housing that ends with a reference to a Wall Street Jounal article dealing with Governor Kohn's speech last week. We discussed this speech in an earlier post. While Barry and I disagree on... [Read More]
Tracked on May 3, 2005 4:10:53 PM
» Anti-Bubble or Anti-Inflation? from None of Your Business
The Big Picture has a great article in reaction to the U.S. Federal Reserve raising interest rates today to 3% called "The Big Picture: Anti-Bubble or Anti-Inflation?" ... [Read More]
Tracked on May 3, 2005 9:19:01 PM
Hobson's Choice -- super-fun bar on Haight Street in San Francisco.
Posted by: seamus | May 3, 2005 7:39:01 PM
The comments to this entry are closed.