Dismal Science ?

Saturday, November 22, 2003 | 07:18 AM

Ever wonder why Economics is called "the dismal science"?

The standard answer is that "19th century author Thomas Carlyle used the phrase to describe the pessimistic theories of Thomas Malthus and David Ricardo, since they predicted decline and fall."

Barron's Gene Epstein takes that old saw to task: He cites economists David M. Levy and Sandra J. Peart essay, "The Secret History of the Dismal Science" as the definitive resolution of the issue:

"Thomas Carlyle did originate the phrase, and he did direct it at economists. But the "scientists" he had in mind were not Ricardo and Malthus, but economists like John Stuart Mill and Harriet Martineau. And their "dismal" offence was to advocate the abolition of slavery.

In a fierce and ongoing debate, the celebrated author of The French Revolution referred to "the Social Science [sic]...which finds the secret of this universe in 'supply-and-demand,' and reduces the duty of human governors to that of letting men alone."

The above is from Carlyle's 1849 essay, "An Occasional discourse on the Negro Question," in which he goes on to use the D-S phrase for the first time. Compared to the "gay science" -- meaning poetry -- he calls economics the "quite abject and distressing...dismal science...led by sacred cause of Black Emancipation."

Epstein further observes "My impression is that Carlyle meant economics was too reductive to recognize the poetry of racial superiority -- and was therefore dismal. -- An essay he published the following year, in which he defended his proposal to re-enslave Jamaicans [!], included the stirring sentence, "Respectable Professors of the Dismal Science, soft you a little!" No examples can be found of his using the phrase in any other way . . ."

My assumption was always that the phrase was not based on the inherent pessimism of its practioners; Rather, I thought the moniker came about simply because economists have such a weak track record in their forecasting follies. Dismal, as in frustrating in their attempts to be more of a Science, and less of an Art. Indeed, I've joked about the difference between Strategists and Economists: The former is usually wrong about the future, while the latter is typically wrong about the past.

The science that liberates? Perhaps not so dismal after all . . .


Economy Finds Strength, White House Loses Way
By Gene Epstein
Barron's, November 24, 2003 

The Secret History of the Dismal Science: Economics, Religion and Race in the 19th Century
David M. Levy, Sandra J. Peart,
Library of Economics and Liberty

Saturday, November 22, 2003 | 07:18 AM | Permalink | Comments (0) | TrackBack (2)
de.li.cious add to de.li.cious | digg digg this! | technorati add to technorati | email email this post



TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Dismal Science ?:

» Neuroeconomics from apostropher
Economics may be "the dismal science," but as science goes, it's as soft and ideological a science as any of the other social sciences, despite using lots and lots of numbers. Almost every economic model rests on the assumption of... [Read More]

Tracked on Mar 22, 2005 11:14:01 AM

» Dismal Day for the Dismal Scientist from Fresh Politics
From the Financial Times, US real wages fall at fastest rate in 14 years: Inflation rose 3.1 per cent in the year to March but salaries climbed just 2.4 per cent, according to the Employment Cost Index. In the final three months of 2004, real wages ... [Read More]

Tracked on May 11, 2005 3:06:39 PM


The comments to this entry are closed.

Recent Posts

December 2008
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31      


Complete Archives List



Category Cloud

On the Nightstand

On the Nightstand

 Subscribe in a reader

Get The Big Picture!
Enter your email address:

Read our privacy policy

Essays & Effluvia

The Apprenticed Investor

Apprenticed Investor

About Me

About Me
email me

Favorite Posts

Tools and Feeds

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Add to Google Reader or Homepage

Subscribe to The Big Picture

Powered by FeedBurner

Add to Technorati Favorites


My Wishlist

Worth Perusing

Worth Perusing

mp3s Spinning

MP3s Spinning

My Photo



Odds & Ends

Site by Moxie Design Studios™